HUB AND SPOKE ROUTE SYSTEM
THE DIFFERENCE:
HUB AND SPOKE VS POINT TO POINT
Point to Point
1. A Point to Point
network is a typical route network where an airline focuses mainly on its
Origin and Destination ( O&D ) traffic.
2. This means that the
airline is more interested in transportation of passengers originating from one
city ( A ) to another ( B ) and vice versa, but not in connecting passengers
between C and B via A.
3. Low Cost Carriers are
considered to be pioneers of this paradigm with a classic example being
Southwest Airlines of US.
Hub and Spoke
A Hub and Spoke network is
a route network where an airline will not only plan on transporting passengers
between two points, but also to connect passengers between two distant cities
via its hub.
An example of a Hub and Spoke network can be seen from the following
diagram.
Imagine that as a bicycle wheel, literally. The airline uses the routes
from its hub to other cities as spokes to connect each of them via its hub.
The Hub and Spoke model
originated with American Airlines, but perhaps the airline that uses it the
best in present day is Emirates Airline.
A Hub and Spoke model
essentially needs to have different banks of flight departues and arrivals – in
order to connect an arrival from city C, with a departure to city B, at the hub
A.
This paves way for the airline to attract highly lucrative transit traffic,
which at some airline contribute more to fill a flight than O&D traffic.
However, this model is not without its downsides. Keeping flights tightly
scheduled to fit this bank might be challenging, and actually operating them on
time to provide the connections might be even more challenging.
However, the advantage, as
well as the increased use of Hub and Spoke models by competitors have forced
not just many legacy full fare carriers but also Low Cost Carriers to embrace a
Hub and Spoke model.
Advantages and
disadvantages hub and spoke system
- Advantages of
hub-and-spoke
The following two points are the major advantages that the hub-and-spoke
system had initially brought to the airline business; however some
disadvantages had been developed later due to changes in external environmental
factors.
- Encouraged the rapid
growth in the airline business
The hub-and-spoke system since developed after deregulation, has allowed
a rapid growth in size, competition strategy and traffic demand in the airline
business. However, as suggested by Wells and Younger (2004 4)
this had resulted in operational inefficiencies at periods of slow economy;
with airlines resulting in very poor financial performances.
As a result of this, some airlines restructure their business model to
return to the point-to-point system and move out of the constant need for a
large hub, and utilise hubs in a more uniform matter in terms of arrivals and
departures. This phenomenon is known as the rolling hubs.
- Efficient use of
scarce transportation resources.
The system has less number of routes connecting all spokes enabling a
more efficient use of scarce transportation resources. This however had small
airports and economies of smaller regions suffering as per the reduced
capacity. As a result this encouraged airports to agree with low cost carriers
to offer low airport fees and commissions from local businesses to bring in
traffic and passenger flow.
The passenger market favoured this type of airline business as lower
fares were rolled out to the market from these smaller hubs; which caused great
competition to full service carriers that were operating with large amount of
airport fees to use large hubs, and can no longer return to these small hub
markets as it is not cost efficient and are dominated by low cost carriers.
Disadvantages of hub-and-spoke
Besides the aforementioned advantages, the hub and spokes system also
holds risks for the airlines and the airports which are highlighted in the following
sections.
- Congestion and delays
at hub airports
To limit waiting times and provide a large variety of possible
connections for passengers at the hub airport, it is essential for the hub
airline to schedule as many incoming and outgoing flights as possible during a
short time frame. This results in high traffic peaks during these times and
often causes delays due to scarce airside facilities such as taxi- or runways.
At the same time the hub-and-spokes-system however allows hub airlines to
increase their benefit exponentially by adjoining an additional destination to
the network compared to point-to-point-carriers. This implies for a hub airline
that usually the trade off between the costs due to congestion and the benefit
of serving new markets is positive. Therefore the airline has an incentive for
adding more traffic despite a rising congestion level. The point-to-point
carriers at the airport which cannot capitalize on such an exponential benefit
however suffer from the increasing number of flights .
Another reason for congestion stems from the fact that many airports do
not limit the number of take-offs and landings. One possibility for airlines to
prevent further congestion and coevally increasing the passenger count is the
use of larger (feeder) aircraft. However, doing so, new challenges occur if these
aircraft with more passengers are delayed. More travelers will miss their
connecting flights which would result in a poor utilization rate of the hub-hub
connection and reduces the profitability of a carrier. This problem is
especially critical for the operations of the A380 .
- Discontinuous use of
airport facilities
The merging of traffic in a hub-and-spoke-system implies a traffic
structure consisting of high peaks at certain times a day when airport
facilities are highly in use. At some airports, costly additional capacity and
infrastructure (e.g. runways) are required to cater for the demands at these
peaks. During off-peak hours, as traffic is less, terminal and airside
facilities are used inefficiently or even idle. The temporal discrepancy
between capacity and demand will continuously result in either congestion and
delays or underutilization .
- Airport dependency
Hub airlines and the corresponding alliances have selected a limited
number of airports on each continent through which they route their traffic.
For these few hub airports in turn, they represent a high share of their
business. As airport capacity is limited and usually not sufficient for other
extensive networks, and the necessary slots at attractive times are not
available, other airlines tend to chose alternative options.
For the airport, this dependency on one major hub airline has advantages and
disadvantages: as long as the airline is stable and successful in the market
the airport can be sure of a consistent operation and therewith a steady income
stream. As soon as the airline however struggles, this will have negative
repercussions on the airport and might severely jeopardize (profitable)
operations at the airport .


.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)