Wednesday, May 7, 2014

Issues and Challenges in Transport Geography

1.                CONGESTION

The issue of congestion is likely to remain as one of great issues in transport geography because there are unprecedented demands for transportation being generated by a global economy that is ever more dependent upon the transport industry. Congestion occurs across modes and locations and arises from two causes. Most important is when demand for mobility exceeds the capacity. It can also occur when random events bring about a temporary disruption to service, such as an accident or a natural hazard such as flooding. In the case of the second causes, it is possible to mitigate their effects if the occurrence is frequent, such as accidents, or if the risks are great, as for example of flooding in a flood plain. A common and attractive solution is to increase capacity. Furthermore, demand is increasing ceaselessly.
The expected growth of the demand is likely to have major impacts on the nature and form of the future transport industry. In the short term at least, road transport is likely to continue its dominance of the transport industry. There are two basic reasons for this assertion. In the developed world automobiles and trucks already dominate the market, and the spatial patterns of people, industries and services have adjusted themselves somewhat to the demands of these modes. Such low density, space extensive patterns are pushing the traffic congestion ever further out, and make it very difficult for other higher capacity modes to compete. At the same time the demand for mobility is growing as a result of the rapid industrialization in developing countries such as China and India. There too a modal shift is occurring in favor of road transport. Increasing prosperity in these countries represents a great potential for growth in road transport.
Congestion is not limited to internal urban-generated traffic. International trade is likely to continue to be dominated by maritime transport (in terms of weight) and air transport (in terms of value). This has already led to a concentration of traffic a relatively small number of gateways and hubs, which are capable of extracting scale economies. For example, the 20 largest container ports handled more than 49% of global traffic in 2010. The traffic concentration however is already producing capacity problems in many of these hubs. International trade has grown at a rate faster than economic growth as measured by the GDP in recent decades and there are expectations that hub congestion will remain an issue in the future.
Congestion is a phenomenon that is spatially bound. It takes place in specific locations with impacts at a multitude of scales, from a particular highway intersection that may delay traffic over a few hundred meters, to blockage in a port that may disrupt the flow of goods over half a continent. Each event produces a spatial response, from the car driver who searches out an alternative route to the shipper who selects a different mode or point of entry for succeeding shipments. Increased demand and the rising likelihoods of congestion will intensify new spatial responses and thus it appears very likely that new spatial flows and structures will come into being. They involve:
  •  Demand management: Concerns the conditions and in what types of locations can travel demand be modified. In a market context, when supply is fixed and demand increases, an upward price adjustment inevitably takes place. This is common in maritime and air transport with yield management strategies. However, many transport infrastructures, such as roads, are provided free of access, implying no cost changes as congestion levels increase. There is thus a growing need to provide incentives (or disincentives) and reassess the priority in the use of infrastructure, particularly in urban areas.
  • Concentration versus deconcentration: Accessibility and infrastructure improvements usually lead to a concentration of activities, while congestion acts as a counteracting force to concentration since it creates various diseconomies. Already there is evidence of deconcentration in air transport for growth in passengers and freight in some smaller airports. The density of economic and social activities and the related intensity of transport use imply a balance between the forces of concentration and deconcentration.
  • Economic and social impacts: In a context where transport networks are increasingly synchronized congestion can create multiplying effects not just impacting costs, but also the reliability of transport systems. The economic and social impacts of congestion remain a salient issue, particularly in developing countries where it can impede economic growth.
  • Passengers versus freight: Congestion also raises the issue of the prioritization of passengers versus freight when they share transport infrastructure or when freight activities such as terminals or distribution centers are in proximity to locations where large numbers of passengers transit. This will require a careful assessment of the respective costs of congestion on specific passenger and freight transport systems and in which circumstances congestion exerts the most externalities. A salient issue concerns how freight distribution could be better integrated in the urban environment where passenger movements tend to dominate; the realm of city logistics.


2.                INFRASTRUCTURE

Regardless of the specific solutions to congestion that are considered, increasing demand is placing unprecedented requests for investments on transport infrastructures. A major question confronting all countries around the world is how to finance the construction and maintenance of transport infrastructures. As economies of scale are applied to transport systems, such as larger containerships or doublestacked rail corridors, capital requirements increase in proportion. Governments have traditionally been the primary source of funding in the transport sector, but the costs of keeping pace with the growth in demand are making it difficult for even the richest countries to countenance public funding on the scale required to meet expectations about the mobility of passengers and freight.
Capital requirements are particularly prevalent on both sides of the infrastructure life cycle spectrum. Over this matter the highways in China and North America represent two salient cases. For China, the last decade has seen an impressive level of highway construction with the setting of a national highway network which totaled more than 85,000 km in 2012, the longest in the world. Comparatively, the American Interstate highway system of about 75,000 km is nearing a phase in its life cycle where a substantial amount of capital investment will be required to upgrade the system and maintain its operability, including thousands of aging highway bridges. While most of the Interstate is publicly funded, almost all Chinese highways were funded by private interests that are using tolls to recover their investments. Irrespective of the context, the issue of the role of private and public actors in transport infrastructure as well as pricing mechanisms will remain salient:

  •  Public-private partnerships and completely private solutions are one set of solutions. For many developing countries this is the only solution, since public finances are inadequate to the task. Thus, in the future, a greater private involvement in the provision of transport infrastructure is to be expected. Several models are already well tested: BOT (Build-Operate-Transfer), where the private sector builds and operates a facility or system for a period of time, but then transfers it back to the government after an agreed period; BLT (Build-Lease-Transfer) where after building the facilities, it is leased for a fixed period for operation, and finally transferred back; ROT (Rehabilitate-Operate-Transfer) where the private party refurbishes an existing facility to be operated for a term prior to be turned back to the state.
  • Pricing. Another approach that is gaining momentum is charging for use of transport infrastructure. Several segments of the transport system are privately owned and operated such as maritime shipping and air transportation implying that pricing is generally set by market forces. Still, many transport infrastructures such are roads and airports are wholly or partially owned by the public sector. Pricing is becoming an important feature of transport planning in urban areas where common use transport infrastructures are under stress. Whether it is cordon pricing, congestion pricing, or tolling, drivers are being forced to pay for their use of roads and limited price elasticity has been observed so far. With the growing concerns over the environment, charging for the externalities of transport modes is becoming a reality in many jurisdictions. It remains to be seen about how effective these alternatives are and their effects on travel behavior.

The difficulties are not to be underestimated, however. Most transport infrastructure projects are long term, but are typified by the heaviest capital investment requirements being incurred over a short initial phase. Even if transport infrastructure can be built in phases most private enterprises cannot take a long term perspective, because they need to cover their expenses and recover their capital investments over short periods of time. With the growing unwillingness or inability of the public sector to fund and provide transport infrastructure, new forms of infrastructure provision, maintenance and operation need to be achieved. This is where the financial sector, particularly long term investment funds (such as pension funds) can be involved with a better synchronism between capital and time horizons of transport infrastructure projects.

3.                SUSTAINABILITY CHALLENGES

The issue of sustainability has become an increasing important consideration for the transport industry. It is now broadly recognized that there needs to be a balance between economic efficiency, social factors and the environment. Of these three, the issue of economic efficiency has always been to the forefront, and governments have been important in regulating social conditions (safety, security, and working conditions). Despite the strong historic relationships between transport and the environment, the latter has tended to be overlooked by the industry. This is changing, and environmental issues are likely to play an ever more important role in the transport industry, particularly over four core dimensions:
  • Transport and climate change. Transportation both influences and is impacted by climate change. Transport activities, particularly vehicles, account for 24% of CO2 emissions worldwide. They are thus subject to regulatory pressures to improve their environmental performance in regard to the greenhouse gases they emit. Concomitantly, transportation activities can be negatively impacted by climate change. Severe weather occurrences have a disruptive effect on transport systems, particularly for air transportation which has become a crucial element of global and regional mobility. Potential impacts on infrastructure need to be assessed since infrastructures are built with an expected life cycle and climate change may reduce it or increase maintenance costs. The prospects of sea level rises are particularly problematic for coastal transport systems. The extent to which climate change is influenced by and will impact global transport systems, for modes and terminals, needs to be seriously considered.
  •  Transport and atmospheric pollution. Air quality standards are being implemented with increasing rigor in more and more countries around the world. There are still striking differences between regions and between the modes. For example, most of the countries of the developing world still have to go a long way to fixing and enforcing standards. However, the trend is towards greater control over emissions, which will have effects on modes and their respective competitiveness, particularly if a mode is subject to a greater degree of legislation than another.
  •  Transport and water quality. The contribution of transport to the pollution of rivers and oceans is considerable, and is only recently being addressed by international legislation. Considerable progress has been made in a number of areas such as ballast water, waste and oil spills. As legislations increase in its comprehensiveness, the more the transport industry is impacted. This is particularly evident in matters relating to dredging, where environmental constraints are placing a growing financial burden on ports that are seeking to deepen channels in order to keep pace with the growth of vessels size. It can be expected that these constraints may impact port competitiveness, particularly in light of the pressures to dredge to keep up with the growth in vessel size.
  •  Transport and land take. Increased demand for transport is already placing enormous pressures for new infrastructures. Many of these transport facilities such as airports and ports require very large amounts of land for their own internal operations and for the external transport links that have to be provided. Rapid motorization in developing countries has resulted in the conversion of land to provide road infrastructure. This expanded scale of transport infrastructure questions the capacity of environmental systems to mitigate the disruptions and will likely have an impact on how transport infrastructure is designed.

No comments:

Post a Comment